Birchbox vs Glossybox: a showdown

5

August 13, 2012 by admin

So this isn’t really a showdown, it’s more like a what do I prefer, what can I afford, why do I really need a monthly beauty supply delivery anyway comparison.  And the showdown merely happened because I saw Glossybox advertised and I thought my life wouldn’t be complete unless I tried it out.

My June Glossybox came in beautiful packaging.

When I opened it up, I saw some decent-sized nice products.

And if I had never had a Birchbox I probably would have looked at them and loved them and raved about this product and signed on for a whole year.

The problem for me is that for around 21 dollars a month (including tax and shipping) I totally expected them to be good and I was underwhelmed with what I got.  For 21 dollars I can get a pretty nice mascara or moisturizer that I really want, rather than a surprise.  There was also no standout product in the box that made me feel like I totally got good value or make-up enlightenment for the price.

What I learned from this experiment is that I think my grab-bag/goodybag spending limit must be 10 bucks. (I can sacrifice 3 lattes a month for a makeup surprise in the mail and be quite content.)  And now I’m wondering what my average yearly makeup expenditure must be.  (How much does one spend in a year that 120-360 dollars a year on a surprise makeup service seem like a good idea? And if Sephora doesn’t make a subscription service soon, is my VIB status in danger of becoming extinct?)  And is there something like this for eco-friendly products?


5 comments

  1. Shannon says:

    Goode Box is Eco friendly 🙂

  2. Goode Box is eco friendly and in between birch box and glossy box as far as price 🙂

  3. […] know how I love me a good makeup subscription service (Hello Birchbox!) or Sephora because I get a bunch of samples with every order.  Well there’s definitely a […]

  4. […] revisited Glossybox for a few months and decided my heart still belongs to Birchbox.  There is no sense in paying 20 dollars for the […]

Sorry, comments are closed.

Places we’ve been

100 places to take kids in the world

Seattle with kids

An Emerald City Life-a blog about a family who loves living in Seattle

About me: Terumi

Terumi-author of An Emerald City Life

Posts you might like:

What I write about:

Find me on Instagram

Instagram

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Superoo!
Legoland Blogger 2016
%d bloggers like this: