Birchbox vs Glossybox: a makeup subscription showdown


August 13, 2012 by admin

So this isn’t really a makeup showdown, it’s more like a what do I prefer, what can I afford, why do I really need a monthly beauty supply delivery anyway comparison.  And the showdown merely happened because I saw Glossybox advertised and I thought my life wouldn’t be complete unless I tried it out.

My June Glossybox came in beautiful packaging.

When I opened it up, I saw some decent-sized nice products.

And if I had never had a Birchbox I probably would have looked at them and loved them and raved about this product and signed on for a whole year.

The problem for me is that for around 21 dollars a month (including tax and shipping) I totally expected them to be good and I was underwhelmed with what I got.  For 21 dollars I can get a pretty nice mascara or moisturizer that I really want, rather than a surprise.  There was also no standout product in the box that made me feel like I totally got good value or make-up enlightenment for the price.

What I learned from this experiment is that I think my grab-bag/goodybag spending limit must be 10 bucks. (I can sacrifice 3 lattes a month for a makeup surprise in the mail and be quite content.)  And now I’m wondering what my average yearly makeup expenditure must be.  (How much does one spend in a year that 120-360 dollars a year on a surprise makeup service seem like a good idea? And if Sephora doesn’t make a subscription service soon, is my VIB status in danger of becoming extinct?)  And is there a makeup subscription like this for eco-friendly products?

Do you have a makeup subscription that you love?  I’d love to know about it!



  1. Shannon says:

    Goode Box is Eco friendly 🙂

  2. Goode Box is eco friendly and in between birch box and glossy box as far as price 🙂

  3. […] know how I love me a good makeup subscription service (Hello Birchbox!) or Sephora because I get a bunch of samples with every order.  Well there’s definitely a […]

  4. […] revisited Glossybox for a few months and decided my heart still belongs to Birchbox.  There is no sense in paying 20 dollars for the […]

Sorry, comments are closed.

Places we’ve been

100 places to take kids in the world

Seattle with kids

An Emerald City Life-a blog about a family who loves living in Seattle

About me: Terumi

Terumi-author of An Emerald City Life

Posts you might like:

What I write about:

Find me on Instagram


Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Legoland Blogger 2016
%d bloggers like this: